Setting reply-time targets your sales team can actually meet

A reply target only helps if people believe it is fair and reachable. Here is a method that starts from your own data.

Published 17 November 2026 · By The Wasla team at Neravo

The short answer

Measure your current median first reply for two weeks, set the first target a little faster than that, and only during working hours. Decide in advance what happens when it is missed: a reminder before the deadline, a move to the next ready person at the deadline, and a message to the team lead after the last move. Review the slowest leads every week and fix causes, not people. Tighten the target only when the team meets it on most days.

Start from what you do today

Most teams pick a target from a blog post or a competitor’s promise. Then the first week shows 40 percent of leads as late, everyone decides the number is unrealistic, and the target is ignored.

Instead, measure for two weeks before you set anything. For each new lead, record when it arrived and when a person first replied. Look at the median (the middle value), not the average, and look at it per hour of the day. You will usually see a good morning, a slow lunch, and a bad late afternoon when site visits and meetings pile up.

Set the first target a little better than today

If your median first reply today is 25 minutes during working hours, a 20-minute target is a stretch people can reach. A 5-minute target would only produce red numbers. Once most days meet 20, move to 15, then 10.

Choose round numbers that are easy to remember. Wasla offers 5, 10, 15 and 30 minutes as presets plus a custom value, because most teams settle on one of those.

Decide what counts and when the clock runs

  • What stops the clock: a message a teammate actually sends. Internal notes, automatic welcome messages and broadcasts should not count.
  • When it starts: when the lead arrives, or, if you count only working hours, when the shift opens. A lead who writes at 11 p.m. should not make the morning team look late.
  • Later replies: a separate, usually longer target for customers who write again after the first reply.
  • Per stage: a lead in negotiation may deserve a faster answer than one in “thinking about it”. Won and lost leads need no clock.

Decide what happens when it is missed

A target with no consequence is a wish. A target whose consequence is a telling-off creates fear and hiding. The consequence should be that the customer still gets an answer:

  1. Remind before the deadline. A nudge to the owner while there is still time, for example at 5 minutes of a 10-minute target.
  2. Move at the deadline. The chat moves to the next Ready person, with its history and notes. Each new owner gets the full target time.
  3. Tell the team lead after the last move. Set how many moves are allowed (often one or two). After the last one the team lead is told and can take over or assign it.

Because every move is written on the chat, nobody has to argue later about who had it.

Make the target reachable in practice

  • Give new chats only to people who are Ready, and set a cap on open chats per person.
  • Match working hours to when leads actually arrive. If most leads come between 6 and 10 p.m., an evening shift helps more than a faster target.
  • Tell the sales team before a big campaign launches.
  • Keep approved templates ready so a first reply takes seconds, not minutes.

The weekly review

Spend 20 minutes a week on three questions:

  1. Did we meet it?. The share of new leads answered within the target, per team and per person, plus the median.
  2. What were the ten slowest?. Open each one and read its trail: when it arrived, who had it, whether it moved, and why it was slow.
  3. What do we change?. Usually a schedule, a cap, a missing template or a form that stopped syncing. Change one thing and look again next week.

Share the numbers with the team, not only with managers. People improve faster when they can see their own reply times next to the target.

Common mistakes

  • Copying another company’s target without measuring your own starting point.
  • Running the clock overnight and on days off.
  • Counting automatic replies as replies.
  • Using the average, which a single forgotten lead can ruin.
  • Ranking people publicly by speed only. Speed matters, but so do the outcomes of those chats.

Questions people ask

What is a good first reply time target for a sales team?

Start a little faster than your current median during working hours, then tighten it as the team meets it. Many teams end up between 5 and 15 minutes for new leads.

What is the difference between a reply target and an SLA?

In a sales team they mean much the same: a promised time to reply. “SLA” comes from support contracts; inside a team it is simply the target you agree to meet.

Should managers see reply times per person?

Yes, and so should each person for themselves. Use it to find causes such as overload or schedule gaps, not to punish.

How often should we change the target?

Review weekly, but change the target only when most days meet it for a few weeks in a row.

Set a reply clock in two minutes

Wasla’s Distribution settings preview who would get the next lead and when it would move. Try it on sample data.